Showing posts with label chinese nationalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chinese nationalism. Show all posts

Thursday, November 20, 2008

Is China a Threat to the U.S.?

With more than two billion residents, the world’s most spoken language and a booming economy, China is undoubtedly a rising global superpower. Suddenly America is faced with the prospect of a country whose financial and military power could soon rival its own, prompting many to wonder if China is a friend or foe. Is China really a red flag for the U.S.? -source-

Normally I'd see this headline-grabbing question as beneath consideration for anyone but the National Security Agency, but since it has come up in more than one casual conversation I realize it holds some importance even among young Americans who missed most of the Cold War. The Tiananmen Square protests probably have a large part to do with that. In any case, it's a worthwhile thought exercise.

Is China a Threat to the U.S.?
Short answer: Nah.
Long answer: If I weren't in the midst of writing a research paper about PRC and US motives for rapprochement in 1972 I would be more than happy to plunge into this issue. But for now the following critique of one expert's answer will have to suffice.

"China remains brutally authoritarian."
The vast majority of Chinese cities live their lives without ever having a bag thrown over their heads and beaten in a government compound. That dissidents are threatened and arrested from time to time is indeed a difference between here and there, however, the vast majority of Chinese will never even come close to that. There are places in the world where the authorities really are brutal and it devalues the term to claim China qualifies. It takes a lot of effort to threaten the Party, and until you do they aren't likely to bother you.

"China's government functions absent the protections of the rule of law."
Sometimes. It's changing.

China's Courts, Tenth "Best" Out of Twelve.

Rule Of China Law And GDP. Was It The Chicken Or The Egg?

China Sex, Prostitutes, Rule of Law, Lines of Power, Unintended Consequences and Bull Connor: A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words. Redux

China Rule Of Law Rising?

The point here isn’t that the commentator is wrong, it’s that he thinks this statement is somehow an indictment of the Party and indicative of why China is a threat. And that demonstrates his lack of expertise, because the lack of rule of law is just one more facet of life in China which matters to Westerners but most Chinese are generally satisfied dealing with. Like pollution. A comparable fact of life in the United States is the democratic enforcement of speech codes which we call “political correctness.” Most Chinese find it a tremendous nuisance for them and might wonder how Americans can live their day to day lives with such oppression. We of course, barely notice. Imagine if Chinese newspapers frequently wrote about how oppressed Americans were by political correctness; we’d be angered or think “they just don’t understand.” Well that’s exactly what’s happening here; this expert American is claiming that, somehow, China's underdeveloped rule of law means the government is running roughshod over the people.

I’d say that rule of law is one aspect of enfranchisement the Chinese people have not yet fully achieved. But brutal authoritarian state it does not make.

“Thus as long as China willingly violates the basic rights of its own people, it can never be trusted to respect the rights of other nations”
This is bullshit. More rights have been violated and more violence has been done to people of the world in the name of American freedom, democracy, and capitalism than will be committed by China in the name of being brutally oppressive motherfuckers. Whether they pay homage to inalienable human rights at the start of every speech or not, the Chinese Communist Party is generally pragmatic and its outlook long-term--since it doesn’t get unelected every 8 years. The Chinese people are generally without idealistic zeal; though even if they were they can't swing the state apparatus into beastmode like Americans can.

If you want to talk about threats, the righteous and freedom-loving goodwill of the American people is a much greater threat to China than Chinese are to Americans. I would trust Chinese to respect the rights of other nations sooner than Americans because Chinese foreign policy doesn’t let their morality interfere with national sovereignty (at least, not since they asserted their own national sovereignty over Tibet, Xinjiang, Mongolia, and others 50 years ago). Or more accurately, national soverignity is an issue of morality for China. The same can not be said about American foreign policy.

-----

Tonight is the first time I've seen it, but the China debate on opposingviews.com doesn't seem particularly researched or thoughtful. For the reader trying to ascertain the relative China threat I suggest starting with the basics before leaping out into predicting the motives and worldview of the CCP.

1. A Long Wait at the Gate to Greatness
2. A Weak China?
Links courtesy of the fantastic chinalawblog.com

Monday, June 2, 2008

The popular dimension of Chinese nationalism

The following quote is from a Facebook wall post:
The bottom line for the government is their continued economic growth, and they need normal relations with the rest of the world in order to maintain it, but the contradiction that poses with the hate propaganda they keep spewing is bound to blow up in their faces at some point.

The so-called "hate propaganda" does blow up in their face. Not dramatically, but enough that it's becoming more common for the government to issue calls for restraint in the media than to try and fan nationalistic flames. Nowadays the Chinese themselves are carrying the torch. The boycott of Carrefour here was allegedly started over phone text messaging, as well as it’s ongoing support by people adding “(l)China” to their MSN names. This is grassroots action, not government nudging. When these grassroots efforts start to put political pressure on the party, or strain international relations the Party asks people to stop.

It also did so in 1999 after the bombing of the Chinese embassy in Belgrade by American forces. When the government didn’t do anything hasty or drastic, popular outrage was expressed in letters to newspapers and on the internet. “The [Americans] know that our government policy is one of merely lodging ‘fierce protests [qianglie kangyi].’ Premier Zhu….Our government’s weak stance has created a distance between itself and the people….You are so capable…and we need you….But without the ‘people’s confidence [minxin]’ how can you lead China’s economic construction!” Surprisingly critical of the government wasn’t it? Instead of the typical support of the government, this kind of expression asks it for action. As a response Hu Jintao gave a speech which urged everyone to get back to work and study. So they (mostly) did.

This is a change from 1996 when the CCP didn't ask the people to do anything, they just outright banned China Can Say No for arbitrarily criticizing party policy. Of course, this is after the book was approved by party apparatus, like all paper publishing is, to this day in China, and after it instigated a lot of nationalist zeal against Japan and the US. Earlier that same year, Japanese boyscouts built a lighthouse on the Diaoyu islands and got China into a flurry. The government response then was just as decisive. They dispersed demonstrations in the street and took away students access to the internet for 10 days when students took their proesting there.
Patriotic actions require guidance.

The public must be dissuaded and prevented from organizing spontaneous meetings, demonstrations and protests.

The publicizing of activities by…printing or distributing documents, or using various means of communication is prohibited.

As you can see by comparison with the 1990's, the policy appears to be changing. This could be a sign of the political reform that the party sees as necessary, or in the words of Peter Gries whose work I borrowed heavily from in the above paragraphs, a sign “The CCP is losing its control over nationalist discourse.” So, if an incident were to "blow up" it wouldn’t just be in the face of the CCP but the people too. Both are responsible for the current nationalism.

With regards to the other part of the original quote, I disagree overall that there’s any threat to China’s economic interests, despite the fact that nationalism and anti-foreign sentiment is on the rise. The government might be vacillating, but I still think it’s at the reigns and not so stupid to jeopardize China’s rise by letting university students actually piss off the world. Besides, whiney students would have to do a lot more than boycott Carrefour for the world to turn its back on Chinese industry and markets. Never underestimate the power of money, or the degree to which the West can write off the views of Chinese people.